Topic Story | J/E | P | Enuma Elish | Rg Veda |
chaos | dry desert: no rain yet | Tehom / watery chaos | watery chaos / Tiamat and Apsu co-mingling | non-existence / meaninglessness/ Purusha |
understanding of God / generative power | Creator - Artisan | Omnipotent Creator | multiple Deities; after initital fight: Marduk as supreme lord | Creator is creation
(even Gods are subsequent to this) |
act of creating | creation with hands: God forms, breathes life, plants garden | creation by divine fiat; creation via separation | creation by decree | creation through sacrifice |
human's role | human is gardener, artisan, participates in creation by naming... | human is priest or controller, has "dominion" over creation | human is subservient subject to monarchic rule in interest of order | human is assigned to caste, but perspective of oneness of all |
hierarchies | gender: woman derivative | animal kingdom | hierarchy among deities, by extension: humans | four varnas |
other structures | structure of universe | structure of time (week) | structure of universe | structure of universe |
human conduct, ritual | obedience | Sabbath | New Year festival | sacrifice |
Anthropology: What does it mean to be human? | partaking in breath of
God (nephesh)
human has soul |
"in the image of God;" partaking in divine essence | humans as servants to the Gods | Purusha is Person / Universe: atman is brahman |
Further questions: Etiologies in these cosmogonies? Perception of time as progressive / linear - repetitious / circular ? Claims on Geography, or a psychological - theological axis mundi (Babylon, Eden and the tree of Life)?